Agenda item
Report of the Member Appointment Process Panel - Appointment of Committee Chairs and Vice-Chairs, Annual Appointments to Committees, Sub-Committees, Panels and Advisory Groups Member Champions and Outside Bodies.
- Meeting of AGM, National Park Authority, Friday 3rd July 2020 10.00 am (Item 39/20)
- View the background to item 39/20
Minutes:
The meeting considered the report of the Member Appointments Process Panel and considered each of the appointments in the order set out in recommendations 2 to 8 in the report. In most cases the appointments were moved, seconded and approved in accordance with the expressions of interest in the report. Any changes to the report are identified below.
Appointment of the Chair of Planning Committee and the Chair of Programmes and Resources Committee.
A motion to appoint Mr R Helliwell as Chair of Planning Committee and Mr Z Hamid as Chair of Programmes and Resources Committee was moved and seconded put to the vote and carried.
Appointment of the Vice Chair of Planning Committee
A motion to appoint one of the following five Members as Vice-Chair of Planning Committee was moved and seconded:
Cllr P Brady,
Cllr M Chaplin,
Cllr D Chapman,
Cllr K Richardson,
Mr K Smith.
Following the first vote there was not a clear majority in favour of one Member so, in accordance with Standing Order 1.12(3), Cllr K Richardson was struck off the list and a fresh vote was taken.
Following the second vote there was not a clear majority in favour of one Member so, in accordance with Standing Order 1.12(3), Cllr D Chapman was struck off the list and a fresh vote was taken.
Following the third vote there was not a clear majority in favour of one Member so, in accordance with Standing Order 1.12(3), Cllr D Chaplin was struck off the list and a fresh vote was taken.
Following the fourth vote Mr K Smith received a majority of the votes cast and was appointed as Vice Chair of Planning Committee.
Vice Chair of Programmes and Resources Committee
A motion to appoint either Cllr C Furness or Prof J Haddock-Fraser as Vice Chair of Programmes and Resources Committee was moved and seconded put to the vote and Prof J Haddock-Fraser was appointed.
Planning Committee and Programmes and Resources Committee
It was noted that the Authority had previously agreed that the Membership of both Standing Committees should be set at 15 and the Local Authority positions on Planning Committee allocated according to the formula used in previous years. At the meeting the Authority agreed to increase the size of Programmes and Resources Committee to 16 Members so that the Chair of the Authority could be appointed to both Committees
Local Joint Committee
At the meeting Cllr K Richardson expressed an interest in being appointed to the Committee.
Appeals Panel
At the meeting Cllr A Hart, Cllr V Priestley and Prof J Haddock-Fraser expressed an interest in being appointed to the Panel.
Budget Monitoring Meeting
At the meeting it was agreed that both Cllr V Priestley and Ms V Witter would be appointed to attend the quarterly meetings.
Natural Environment , Biodiversity and Farming Member Champion
A motion to appoint one of the following five Members as the Natural Environment , Biodiversity and Farming Member Champion was moved and seconded:
Cllr D Chapman,
Cllr Ms C Farrell,
Mr R Helliwell,
Cllr V Priestley,
Miss L Slack.
Following the first vote there was not a clear majority in favour of one Member so, in accordance with Standing Order 1.12(3), Cllr V Priestley was struck off the list and a fresh vote was taken.
Following the second vote there was not a clear majority in favour of one Member and both Cllr C Farrell and Mr R Helliwell had the lowest number of votes. Mr Helliwell then withdrew his expression of interest so a fresh vote was taken with his name removed.
Following the third vote there was not a clear majority in favour of one Member so, in accordance with Standing Order 1.12(3), Cllr Ms C Farrell was struck off the list and a fresh vote was taken.
Following the fourth Miss L Slack received a majority of the votes cast and was appointed as the Natural Environment , Biodiversity and Farming Member Champion.
Thriving and Sustainable Communities
A motion to appoint either Cllr P Brady or Cllr V Priestley as the Thriving and Sustainable Communities Member Champion was moved and seconded, put to the vote and Cllr V Priestley was appointed.
Appointments to Outside Bodies
Derwent Valley Community Rail Partnership |
Cllr A McCloy expressed an interest in being appointed as Deputy. |
Moors for the Future Partnership Group |
It was moved and seconded that either Miss L Slack or Cllr R Walker be appointed as Deputy Chair. The motion was put to the vote and Miss L Slack was appointed. Miss L Slack withdrew her interest as being appointed as a reserve Member. |
Staffordshire Destination Management Partnership |
Cllr A Hart expressed an interest in being appointed. |
National Park Management Plan Advisory Group |
Mr J Berresford withdrew his expression of interest. |
RESOLVED
1. To confirm that voting on recommendations 2 to 8 in the report be carried out using a WebEx poll instead of a recorded vote.
2. To confirm that the size of Planning Committee is set to 15 Members made up of 8 Local Authority Members and 7 Secretary of State Members with Local Authority places on Planning Committee as set out in Section B(i) of Appendix 1.
3. To confirm that the size of Programmes and Resources Committee is set to 16 made up of 8 Local Authority Members and 8 Secretary of State Members
4. To appoint the following Members to the offices of Chair and Vice Chair of the Standing Committees until the Annual Meeting in July 2021:
Planning Committee |
Chair: Mr R Helliwell Vice Chair: Mr K Smith
|
Programmes and Resources Committee |
Chair: Mr Z Hamid Vice Chair: Prof J Haddock-Fraser
|
5. To appoint Members to Planning Committee, and the Programmes and Resources Committee as set out below until the Annual Meeting in July 2021:
|
|
Planning Committee
|
Programmes and Resources |
Chair: Mr R Helliwell Vice Chair: Mr K Smith
|
Chair: Mr Z Hamid Vice Chair Prof J Haddock Fraser
|
Cllr J W Armitage Cllr R P H Brady Cllr M Chaplin Cllr D Chapman Cllr A Gregory Cllr A Hart Cllr I Huddlestone Cllr A McCloy Cllr Mrs K Potter Cllr K Richardson Miss L Slack Cllr G Wharmby 1 Vacancy
|
Cllr J Atkin Mr J Berresford Cllr C Farrell Cllr C Furness Cllr Mrs C G Heath Cllr B Lewis Cllr A McCloy Cllr C McLaren Cllr V Priestley Cllr P Tapping Cllr R Walker Mrs C Waller Ms Y Witter Cllr B Woods
|
6. To appoint the following Members to the Local Joint Committee until the Annual Meeting in July 2021:
Cllr W Armitage Cllr M Chaplin Cllr C Furness Cllr I Huddlestone Cllr K Richardson
|
Cllr Mrs K Potter Mr K Smith Prof J Haddock Fraser Cllr V Priestley |
7. To appoint the following Members to the Appeals Panel until the Annual Meeting in July 2021:
Cllr M Chaplin Cllr D Chapman Cllr I Huddlestone Cllr A Hart Cllr B Woods
|
Cllr R P H Brady Mr R Helliwell Prof J Haddock Fraser Cllr V Priestley |
8. To appoint the following Members to the Due Diligence Panel until the Annual Meeting in July 2021:
One Member One Deputy Member: |
Mr J Berresford Cllr C Furness
|
9. To appoint the following Members to the Local Plan Review Steering Group until the Annual Meeting in July 2021:
Chair of Planning Committee Vice Chair of Planning Committee:
Chair of the Authority
Member Representatives:
|
Mr R Helliwell Mr K Smith
Cllr A McCloy
Cllr C Furness Prof J Haddock-Fraser Cllr V Priestley Miss L Slack Mr K Smith Ms Y Witter
|
10. To appoint the following Members to the Governance Review Working Group until the Annual Meeting in July 2021:
Cllr W Armitage Cllr C Furness Cllr B Woods
|
Mr J Berresford Cllr R P H Brady Cllr A McCloy Mr K Smith |
11. To appoint the following Members to the Climate Change Task Group until the Annual Meeting in July 2021:
Cllr C Farrell Cllr C Furness Cllr D Chapman Cllr M Chaplin
|
Prof J Haddock-Fraser Miss L Slack Mr K Smith
|
12. To appoint the following Members to the Budget Monitoring Meeting until the Annual Meeting in July 2021:
Chair and Vice Chair of Programmes and Resources Committee:
Chair of the Authority:
Two other Members:
|
Mr Z Hamid Prof J Haddock-Fraser
Cllr A McCloy
Cllr V Priestly and Ms Y Witter |
13. To appoint the following Member Champions until the Annual Meeting in July 2021:
Natural Environment, Biodiversity and Farming: |
Miss L Slack |
Cultural Heritage and Landscapes: Engagement: Thriving and Sustainable Communities: Climate Change: Business Economy: Member Learning and Development:
|
Mr K Smith Ms Y Witter Cllr V Priestly Prof J Haddock-Fraser Cllr C Furness Cllr B Woods |
14. To make appointments to the Outside Bodies set out in Appendix 1 to the minutes to expire at the Annual meeting in July 2021.
15. To confirm that only these appointments are approved duties for the payment of travel and subsistence allowances as set out in Schedule 2 in the Members’ Allowances Scheme.
Supporting documents:
- Report of the Member Appointment Process Panel - Appointment of Committee Chairs and Vice-Chairs, Annual Appointments to Committees, Sub-Committees, Panels and Advisory Groups Member Representatives and Outside Bodies., item 39/20 PDF 342 KB
- Appendix 1 Report of the Member Appointment Process Panel, item 39/20 PDF 296 KB
- Appendix 2 - Member Statements, item 39/20 PDF 421 KB