Agenda item

Full Application - Section 73 - Variation or removal of conditions 1, 2, 5, 6, 8, 10, 12, 13, 14 and 15 on application NP/DDD/0615/0601, Brookfield Manor, Main Road, Hathersage, S32 1BB

Minutes:

Members had visited the site on the previous day.

 

The Planning Officer reported an amendment to Condition 15 of the report to state “marquee should be fully dismantled and removed from the site within three days of the event” not four.

 

The Planning Officer stated that the original application which was granted in January 2016 for a trial period of 3 years, expiring at the end of January 2019. The application was to hold wedding events/functions for up to 8 per year, but  since the approval was given and due to the restrictions imposed to control the use, only 4 events have actually taken place.

 

The Officer also reported that since the report was written, a further letter of representation had been received from the residents of Cow Close Farm, and this was summarised for Committee.

 

The following spoke under the Public Participation at Meetings Scheme:-

 

·         Mr Eric Marsh, Supporter

·         Mr Derek Latham, on behalf of the applicant

 

A motion for approval subject to conditions as set out in the report was moved and seconded.

 

The Planning Officer reported that  the applicant  had agreed to a further trial period of 5 years, but  Members felt that  by extending this to 7 years was more realistic and reasonable for monitoring purposes, to assess the impact on  the amenity and business certainty.

 

Concern was raised by Members over the lack of disabled car parking spaces available. The Planning Officer confirmed  that although this had been covered in Condition 18 of the original application, he would go back to the Applicant to confirm  the arrangements.

 

A motion for approval for an amendment to the motion for 7 years was moved and seconded.  This was then voted on and carried and became the substantive motion.

 

The following amendments to conditions were agreed:-

 

4 – include ‘and/or functions’ after wedding

10 – include time limit of 10.30pm

22 – include “release of balloons”

 

Footnote regarding disabled parking.

 

The recommendation to approve the application with the stated amendments to the conditions set out in the report was moved, seconded, put to the vote and carried.

 

 

RESOLVED

To APPROVE the application subject to the following conditions:

 

1.    The development hereby permitted shall not be carried out otherwise than in complete accordance with the following approved plans: the 1:10,000 location plans reference 'RB1 a' and 'RB1 b' both received by the National Park Authority on the 27 November 2015, the 1:500 'Brookfield Manor curtilage car park' plan and the 'curtilage car park location plan' both received by the National Park Authority on the 30 December 2015, the following plan numbers: '2154 PAV 3A' dated 6 April 2015, '2154 PAV 4' dated 28 August 2015, '2154 PAV 5' dated 17 September 2015, '2154 PAV 11' and '2154 PAV 12' both dated 15 October 2015, '2154 PAV 12 B' dated 22 December 2015, ‘2154 PAV 13  A’ dated 4 December 2017, ‘2154 PAV 13.1’ dated 4 December 2017, the revised arrival and departure protocol dated December 2017, the revised noise management protocol dated December 2017 and the specification for the proposed 'GP flex' system by elite GSS Ltd dated 24 December 2015, subject to the following conditions or modifications:

 

2.    The development shall be limited to a period of 7 years.

 

 

 

3.     The use hereby approved shall be limited to weddings or functions held ancillary to Brookfield Manor only and for no other purposes. The existing dwelling and the buildings and land subject to this application shall be maintained as a single planning unit. The owner shall maintain a register of any wedding and function bookings (including the planned date, start time and estimated number of guests) for each calendar year which shall be made available for inspection by the Authority on request.

 

4.    The use hereby approved to host weddings and / or functions shall not take place on more than eight occasions in any one calendar year. No more than one wedding and / or functions shall take place in any five day period.

 

5.    The rating level of the noise emitted from the site shall not exceed the existing background noise level [determined to be 32dB(A)LA90] by more than 5 dB(A) at any time. The noise levels shall be determined at the closest point, in a free field position, adjacent to the nearest dwelling house at Cow Close Farm, Hathersage which exists at the date of this planning permission.

 

6.    Amplified music (including from any pre-recorded or live performance) shall only be played through the ‘Zone Array’ system within appendix B of the submitted noise management protocol dated 8 October 2015.

 

7.    No amplified music shall be played outside of the pavilion building at any time.

 

8.    No amplified music shall be played after 00:30 (the day following the start of the wedding or function).

 

9.    No acoustic music shall be played after 18:00 hours.

 

10. Details of how amplified speeches are to be controlled to be agreed before any other events take place and only allowing speeches before 10.30pm.

 

11. The hours of operation for any wedding / function (including the departure of all guests) shall be limited to between the hours of 08:00 - 01:00 the following day. All staff shall leave by no later than 01:30 the following day.

 

12. The hours of operation for setting up before / clearing up after any wedding / function (including clearing up and disposing of any waste following an event) shall be limited to between the hours of 08:00 - 20:00 hours Monday - Friday and 10:00 - 17:00 on Saturday, Sundays and on Bank Holidays.

 

13. The hours of operation for erecting and dismantling the steel frame of any marquee shall be limited to between the hours of 09:00 - 17:00 hours Monday - Friday and 10:00 - 16:00 on Saturday, Sundays and on Bank Holidays.

 

 

 

 

 

14. No marquee shall be erected other than in complete accordance with approved plans: drawing numbers '2154 PAV11', '2154 PAV 12' both dated 1 October 2015, ‘2154 PAV 12 B’ dated 15 October 2015, ‘2154 PAV 13 A’ dated 4 December 2017 and ‘2154 PAV 13.1’ dated 4 December 2017.

 

15. No marquee shall be erected earlier than seven days prior to an event and all marquees shall be fully dismantled and removed from the site within three days of the end of an event.

 

16. The total number of guests (not including staff) shall not exceed 150 at any time.

 

17. The acoustic screens shown on approved plans: drawing numbers '2154 PAV 3A' dated 6 April 2015 and '2154 PAV 4' dated 28 August 2015 shall be retained in position and maintained throughout the lifetime of the development hereby approved.

 

18. No planning permission is granted for the air cooling units shown on the specified approved plan which shall be omitted from the scheme.

 

19. No vehicles shall be parked other than in accordance with the following approved plans: the 1:500 'Brookfield Manor curtilage car park' plan and the 'curtilage car park location plan' both received by the National Park Authority on the 30 December 2015 and drawing number '2154 PAV 12 B' dated 22 December 2015 which show the proposed pavilion and curtilage car parks. No more than 16 vehicles shall be parked on the pavilion car park after 20:00. No vehicles shall be parked on the pavilion car park after 22:00.

 

20. Signage to identify the pavilion car park, curtilage car park and the proposed pick-up point shall be erected in accordance with the scheme approved by the Authority by decision notice on the 5 April 2016 (application reference NP/DIS/0216/0105).

 

21. Lighting shall only be installed in accordance with the scheme approved by the Authority by decision notice on the 5 April 2016 (application reference NP/DIS/0216/0105) or in accordance with an alternative scheme which shall have first been submitted to and approved in writing by the National Park Authority.

 

22.There shall be no firework, airborne lantern, release of balloons or similar displays associated with the use hereby approved carried out on site or on land within the applicant’s ownership or control.

 

FOOTNOTE:-

That discussion takes place between the Applicant and Officers in terms of arrangements to disabled parking. 

 

 

 

Supporting documents: